Back to National Assembly for Wales Homepage Subject Index  The Richard Commisssion
       
     
   
 
Welsh Assembly Government News * Members * Consultation * Calendar of events * Library of evidence * Frequently asked questions * External Links * Contact us
*
 

Response from Usk & District Labour Party to the Richard Commission

The Branch discussed the questions raised by the Commission, at its meeting on 24th June and wishes to comment as follows.
  1. Some of the issues raised are matters for those with a close working knowledge of the Assembly and the Branch felt that it could not usefully comment on these.
  1. The Branch strongly disapproves of the additional member system. The additional members do not have constituency responsibilities and it is difficult to see that they have a useful role. It is particularly unfortunate when candidates who are rejected by the electors have a second bite of the cherry by virtue of being on the list and this possibility should be closed off. If the system is abandoned and an element of PR is sought, this could be achieved by the single alternative vote but the Branch did not wish to exclude other ways of doing so.
  1. The Branch did not see the need for a greater number of AMs.
  1. Some of the high visibility policies adopted by the Assembly (e.g., abolition of 7 year old SATs and free buses for the over 60s) were welcomed. The Branch had the impression that existing powers were used effectively but it did not have detailed information. The Branch would favour, at some future stage, the granting of tax raising powers and responsibility for primary legislation but did not feel that the Assembly was ready for this immediately.

David Collard
Branch Secretary