Back to National Assembly for Wales Homepage Subject Index  The Richard Commisssion
       
     
   
 
Welsh Assembly Government News * Members * Consultation * Calendar of events * Library of evidence * Frequently asked questions * External Links * Contact us
*
 

Written response received from Jonathan Brown 29 September 2003

I have watched this debate (or lack of it) with interest. We live in a constitutional monarchy of
unequal parts (ie the U.K.)
In other countries that have regional or provincial government, devolved responsibilities
are clear and equal, this allows for both proper central planning and set parameters for
effective local divergence (and equal rights for citizens in a constitutional framework
it also strengthens both local and national identity ie Canada/provinces, Australia/states USA/states).
England, Scotland, Wales and N Ireland should all get equally devolved powers - we will then know
what the UK stands for!
The current situation in Wales is a mess - people are confused as to who is responsible for what,
with some justification it can be argued Wales has worst of all worlds accountability in Cardiff
and power without accountability in London.
Wales needs a parliament similar to Scotland with clearly defined responsibilities.   We cannot have
effective joined up social policies with issues such as policing being driven in London and education,
health, Housing in Cardiff.
Equality in treatment of Home Nations will strengthen and not divide U.K.   Inequality may well lead
to its eventual collapse and slow disintegration.
This is a non political but common sense view from a balanced ordinary member of the public whose
views frequently fail to get heard or reflected by political parties.
My details have been withheld as I hold a position which does not allow me to express political
views.
Many thanks - best of luck with review
Jon Brown